Daily Archives: May 15, 2017

A Total Cost of Ownership Comparison of ZOE Vs CLIO

At Fuel Included, we have run our Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) Calculator on a real-life example to help show the way the costs break down, and the considerable savings that can be made.

Today we have gone head to head with an all Electric Renault ZOE Dynamique 40 kWh, and a Petrol engined Renault CLIO Dynamique Nav TCe 90.

Renault ZOE and Renault CLIO

We have taken a commuter travelling into central Milton Keynes each day and parking as our representative driver. These tables show the total monthly cost* by summing all costs for the three year period of the lease and dividing them by 36.

Total Cost of Ownership

Electric ZOE Vs Petrol CLIO cost comparison for 20,000 miles per year
Electric ZOE Vs Petrol CLIO cost comparison for 15,000 miles per year
Electric ZOE Vs Petrol CLIO cost comparison for 10,000 miles per year

Conclusions

Even at the lower ranges of driving there are significant cost savings to be made. However, we see that as the mileage increases, the money to be saved is simply staggering.

Please contact us if you would like us to assess the cost of ownership of an electric car for your use case.

*Assumptions made for these calculations:

  • Petrol price from Sainsbury’s Bedford £1.21 per litre.
  • Electric charging is home charging plus 10 charges per year at £6 per charge from the Ecotricity rapid charge network.
  • CLIO mpg 52 from https://www.honestjohn.co.uk/realmpg/renault/clio-iv-2013
  • Both cars taken on 3 year PCP. Clio prices from http://offers.renault.co.uk/cars/clio/selection?offer=305 and ZOE prices from our current Fuel Included offer.
  • ZOE miles/kWh 4.5 from manufacturers real-world mileage figure divided by battery capacity.
  • Home charging Economy-7 unit cost 7.5p
  • Tax: Clio 1.2L 118 g/km CO2 = £160 in year 1 and £140 per year subsequently.
  • Parking costs based on person parking 200 working days per year in Milton Keynes town centre

Plug-in electric does what you’d expect from a normal car, which is a good thing

“Electric cars are taking over! Autonomous cars will rule the road! The end of oil is nigh!”

Sigh. If you’re like me, you’re tired of all the rhetoric of how the auto industry is on the cusp of major change, like, any day now. Hell, I spent enough time reading my dad’s old copies of Popular Mechanics from the 1960s and ’70s. If you believed those stories, then today we should all be soaring over roads in flying cars, gently setting down in our suburbia-heaven driveways after a long day of work, your wife greeting you at the door in a dress and pearls with a martini in hand.

We all know how that worked out. As for autonomous cars, they are at least 10 to 15 years from being viable on a mass scale – there’s no way they could even get out of the driveway in Canadian winters with current technology. And electric vehicles (EVs), while having come a long way in the last 20 years, still make up less than 1 per cent of all vehicles sold in North America. Gasoline-guzzling trucks and SUVs are by far the biggest sellers here. So, considering all the facts, you’ll excuse me if I’m more than a little skeptical on how soon this sea of change will come.

Ah, not so fast: I just had a chance to drive “the future,” and I admit I was impressed. And what impresses me the most about it has nothing to do with sci-fi wizardry or space-age design; no, what impresses me is that it’s almost completely, well, normal.

This is the new Hyundai Ioniq, a full-on, battery-powered electric vehicle. Only, you wouldn’t necessarily know it’s an EV if you saw it in someone’s driveway; the only giveaways being the word “electric” on the trunk lid (obvious) and the closed faux-grille at the front (not so obvious). No, this is not an overblown golf cart or futuristic science experiment; the Ioniq is a handsome car that fits in with the rest of Hyundai’s design language – not to mention any other car on the road. The front-wheel-drive hatchback has a wheelbase of 2,700 millimetres, about the size of the compact Elantra; LED lights fore and aft give this top-of-the-line Limited model a more upscale look, while the body-coloured wheels are a nice touch, too.

Inside, it’s more of that normal – no, don’t worry, that’s a good thing, especially as it continues the upscale feel. Nicely textured soft materials on the dash and doors, subtle bronze-coloured accents, simple, well laid-out controls, and a nifty TFT screen for the instrument cluster, which changes colours and details depending on the drive mode. In fact, this Ioniq Limited has an impressive list of features to coddle its passengers: adaptive cruise control, heated seats both front and rear, automatic climate control and a giant 8-inch infotainment screen, among many others.

The ride is comfortable, handling is competent for a sedate compact hatchback (though the steering is vague and over-boosted), the interior is roomy and relatively quiet and it looks sharp. Overall, the Ioniq would be a good choice for someone in the market for a compact hatch. In other words, this electric car is like a normal car.

Read more: Driving.ca